Playbook: How to Win a Competitive Best of Franchise

At Omaha Magazine, the number one driver of email subscribers – currently 200,000 in a DMA of just over a million – is the Best of Contest, which gets 60,000 to 70,000 votes a year.

Todd Lemke, founder and publisher, shared his “Best of” playbook developed over 42 years of running the contest, as the magazine evolved from paper ballots to using the Best of to curate audience data –  and dominating the franchise despite numerous competitors, including the daily newspaper.

WELCOME TO THE NICHE PUBLISHER NETWORK

Join the Network to continue reading the report

Join the Network! As a member, you can:

  • Compare your company to industry benchmarks in your private dashboard
  • Join private publisher roundtables on critical issues
  • Find technology recommended by peers
  • Connect directly with peers you meet
  • Download resources like How to Build AI Agents, Top Media Kits, Best Revenue Ideas This Year, and more

Meet your peers. Learn faster. Build smarter. See you on the inside!

Connect with top publishers

Related Articles

How Active Norcal builds, prices & packages 20 million social follows

When Zach O'Brien attended his first Niche Media Conference ten years ago, he was inspired to found ActiveNorcal, a bi-monthly magazine on outdoor activities in Northern California. O'Brien enlisted other family members and used his background working in PR for the NBA. Originally he posted all the articles on Facebook when the magazine was published.

By 2016, however, O'Brien noticed something unexpected. While the magazine circulation was 10,000 every other month, the website traffic had 50,000 visitors.

"We were putting 99% of our effort into the print magazine but getting quadruple the unique visitors online. A digital native, he decided to discontinue the physical magazine and transition his customer base to an all-digital business model.

There was just one catch.

Please become a member to continue reading this and other peer-shared strategies in the Resource Center.

Insightful Accountant dives into recurring sponsorship revenues

What if you could attract new advertisers, increase revenue, and build more predictable income—all by changing how you sell advertising?

That's what Insightful Accountant set out to do when it bundled performing and underperforming advertising opportunities, social media collaboration and discounted pricing into monthly, auto-renewing sponsorship subscriptions.

Ten months later, the results are impressive:

22 advertisers signed up, about half of them new customers.

Six subscription tiers, priced from $500 to $3,000 monthly.

More than $20,000 in estimated monthly recurring revenue heading into 2027.

In our new case study, co-founder Gary DeHart explains how the company structured its packages, added value with video and other services, and transformed advertising sales into ongoing marketing relationships.

Read the case study and watch our interview to learn how the model works—and what other publishers can borrow.

Never miss a trick! Get updates on new reports weekly