Pop-ups work. Here’s how to make them less annoying

In general pop-ups, whether sold to advertisers or used to convert subscribers – increase conversions.  They can also provide information that the audience may not find on their own, such as a special subscription offer that otherwise would be hidden behind the subscribe button.

However, pop-ups can also be annoying to visitors: Only 21% of visitor found them helpful, while 23%  dislike them, according to a study by JustinMind.

So how can publishers make their pop-up strategies less annoying? The key seems to be how pop-ups are used.

Here’s what the research shows factors in:

• The right Size

A desktop pop-up should be  500×400, mobile pop-up should be  375×660 to optimize registrations. Larger desktop pop-ups can look like the publisher is shouting at the visitor.

• The right timing

Wait a bit. 90% of pop-ups have higher conversion rates after 4 seconds. 

A pop-up that appears just as the visitor is finding an entry point to read something on the page is perceived as more interruptive.

• Tailor to specific content

If the user is accessing events,  promise events alerts. If the user is accessing product reviews, promise they will be the first to know if they sign up for the email.

Niche publishers have an advantage over more generalized publishers in that their content – and the newsletter updates – is already specialized for an exclusive audience, however the principle is the.

• Include something special

Along these lines, add a helpful e-book on the subject matter.  Informational ebooks alone have shown to convert at the rate of 2% plus, or 2 per 100 unique views.

The type of content depends on the media. A media that review restaurants could give a recipe e-book for what 10 local chefs food at home – after four seconds, of course!

• Express the unique benefit

Even if there is no offer, nich media provides information readers can’t find anywhere else.

The readers is visiting the niche publishing site for a reason, understand what motivates them and make a promise in return for a sign-up. See ten great ideas for increasing pop-up registrations that all convey a unique value proposition.

•Use a conversational voice and great visuals.

Pop-ups are like advertisements. How can you make them fun, and stress free? Tampa Magazine shows a great image of a beach. CQ shows a guy in a suit standing in a swimming pool.

•Use cookies to limit their use per visitor and consider an interstitial offer

A softer way to attract a sign-up is to embed a form as an interstitial in the middle of an article, a tactic used by Digiday. The advantage is that the offer waits until the visitor has spent some time reading and article and includes it inside the text  – unlike waiting for them to click on a subscribe link elsewhere.

 

In summary, publishers can’t remove all pop-ups and maintain the same conversion rates, but they can work to make them as appealing as possible.

Related Articles

Case Study: Publisher Builds AI-Powered Sales Team

As a niche publisher in the fishing and outdoor industry, Angie Thompson knew her sales reps were capable — but could go into calls better prepared by using AI.  Without total confidence from knowing what to pitch to whom, reps would default to emails. It was also a struggle to walk into a trade show with a hundred booths, not knowing who to prioritize and exactly how to start the conversation.   Here’s her strategy and the pay off.

Zero to 10,000 in one year: Using WIZA to build the B2B audience

When NichePublisher.biz got started in 2023 , there was only a small list shared by a niche media association along with a stack of business cards from its conference. 

It would not be enough to quickly build the minimum of 10,000 B2B emails needed to power its newsletter-first model. 

The strategy that succeeded at scale was to use WIZA to find emails for publishers found on LinkedIn Sales Navigator.  Here’s how it works:

Never miss a trick! Get updates on new reports weekly